Skip to main content
01908 597094 (Phone & WhatsApp)
f
TAGS
H

Reclaim Your Tax! The Four Words Every Business Owner Should Treat With Caution

A brand new client recently forwarded me a report with a simple question:

"Does this look right to you?"

The report claimed there could be significant tax relief available on a commercial property purchase made years ago. It looked impressive at sixteen pages long with professional branding, detailed calculations, references to legislation, plenty of technical terminology.

At first glance, it appeared that someone had carried out a detailed analysis of the building and identified hidden tax savings. But there was one problem, nobody had actually visited the property. My heart sank, a brand-new client that we then have to tell them the report they have paid for is useless.

The Rise of the Tax Reclaim Industry

Over the last few years, a whole industry has emerged around finding "missed" tax reliefs.

You may have received calls, emails or letters saying:

  • We can reclaim your business rates.

  • We can reduce the VAT on your energy bills.

  • We can identify unclaimed capital allowances.

  • We can recover Stamp Duty Land Tax.

  • We can increase your R&D tax claims.

  • We can find money your accountant has missed.

The marketing is usually very persuasive because it appeals to a fear every business owner has, What if I've paid more tax than I needed to?

That's a perfectly reasonable concern, even we ask that question on our own business

The difficulty is that many of these firms are not selling tax savings, they're selling a report and those are not always the same thing. HMRC also have concerns regarding the practice of some Tax Reclaim businesses.

If Nobody Had Seen The Building, How Detailed Can The Report Really Be?

The report we reviewed described itself as a desktop assessment and confirmed that no physical survey had been undertaken. Yet it still managed to estimate values for all sorts of specialist assets supposedly within the property.

These included:

  • Electrical installations

  • Fire and security systems

  • Data communication systems

  • Heating and extraction equipment

  • Compressed air services

  • Manufacturing and process plant

  • Specialist finishes

All allocated monetary values and all contributing towards a potential capital allowances claim.

Now, perhaps some of those items existed, perhaps all of them did. But if you've never walked through the building, opened a plant room, inspected a workshop or seen the electrical installation, how confident can anybody be?

It's a little like valuing the contents of a house from Google Street View.

You might get some things right.

You might get some things very wrong.

The Magic of Benchmarks

One of the most interesting aspects of the report was that it relied heavily on benchmark assumptions. Essentially, because the property fell into a particular category, assumptions were made about what would typically be present in that type of building.

The danger is obvious, no two buildings are identical. One warehouse may have extensive mechanical systems, security controls and production equipment. The next may be little more than four walls and a roller shutter door.

Tax claims should ideally be built on evidence.

Not assumptions.

The Small Print Matters

Many business owners read the front page.

Few read the disclaimers.

Buried within the report were statements explaining that:

  • It was not tax advice.

  • It was not accounting advice.

  • It was not legal advice.

  • Responsibility for any claim ultimately sits with the taxpayer.

And that's the point every business owner should understand.

If HMRC ever asks questions about a claim, it is generally the taxpayer who must justify the position taken. The glossy report may be long forgotten by that stage.

Capital Allowances Are Not The Villain

Let me be absolutely clear.

Capital allowances are a legitimate and valuable area of tax relief. In the right circumstances they can save businesses thousands of pounds. In fact, we've successfully identified worthwhile claims for clients where relief would otherwise have been overlooked.

The issue isn't capital allowances. The issue is being persuaded to incur substantial fees before establishing whether a meaningful opportunity actually exists.

Sometimes there is.

Sometimes there just isn't.

It's Not Just Capital Allowances

The same pattern appears in several areas of tax.

Business Rates Reviews

Many businesses are told they've been overpaying non-domestic rates. Occasionally that's true.

However, before engaging a specialist, it is worth asking:

  • What specific error has been identified?

  • Is there evidence of an incorrect valuation?

  • How much is realistically recoverable?

  • What percentage fee will be charged?

A speculative challenge isn't the same as a genuine overpayment.

VAT On Energy

This is particularly common amongst farms, mixed-use properties and businesses operating from home. We've seen countless approaches suggesting businesses, charities and community buildings are automatically entitled to reduced-rate VAT on electricity.

Sometimes they are.

Sometimes part of the supply qualifies.

Sometimes none of it does.

The answer depends entirely on how the electricity is used, not on a standard marketing template. An error on VAT can quickly become very costly, often business targeted for VAT relief are not VAT registered, so those errors move from ‘paper errors’ to real hard cash!

R&D Tax Claims

For years, some firms encouraged clients to submit R&D claims on the broadest possible interpretation of the rules. HMRC has since increased scrutiny significantly.

Many valid claims remain.

Many others never should have been submitted.

A claim being possible is not necessarily the same thing as a claim being robust.

The Question Every Business Owner Should Ask

Whenever someone says:

"We can reclaim tax for you."

Don't start by asking:

"How much?"

Instead ask:

"How do you know?"

How do you know there's a claim?

How do you know it hasn't already been made?

How do you know the fee is justified?

How do you know the claim will stand up to scrutiny?

A genuine specialist should welcome those questions.

A salesperson may not.

The Best Tax Saving We Found

In this particular case, the biggest saving wasn't a tax refund.

It was trying helping the client avoid spending money on a report that was unlikely to produce meaningful additional benefit. Unfortunately, in this case it was too late, £1600 had already been spent, the report? Absolutely useless! 

Sometimes good advice isn't about helping a client reclaim tax.

Sometimes it's about helping them keep hold of their cash in the first place.